Hybrid approach for long-standing persistent atrial fibrillation: immediate versus staged treatment

Background The hybrid approach has become the most effective treatment option for restoring sinus rhythm and reducing the risk of atrial fibrillation (AF) recurrence. However, several issues remain to be clearly defined, including the appropriate timing of the staged procedure and the most effective strategy. Methods Over a 12-year period of activity, we performed 609 AF ablation procedures via a right mini-thoracotomy. From this general population, 60 patients underwent a hybrid procedure with catheter ablation performed at least 4 weeks after the surgical procedure to confirm if effective complete electrical isolation of pulmonary veins was achieved. In 20 patients, the second stage procedure was performed during the same hospitalization due to patient's electrical instability. The results obtained in immediate versus staged patients were compared. Results All patients were discharged after the first stage procedure in sinus rhythm. The 20 immediate patients had a shorter hospital stay compared with the staged patients, in whom the two hospitalizations resulted in a longer hospital stay (immediate 5.5 +/- 1.6 days versus staged 8.7 +/- 1.4, P < 0.001). A significantly higher number of immediate patients had an associated ablation of the Bachmann's bundle (n = 16 in the immediate group [80%] versus n = 14 in the staged group [45%]; P = 0.001). After a mean follow-up of 74 months, there was no significant difference in the risk of AF relapse between groups (immediate 1/20 [5%] versus staged 7/40 [17.5%]; P = 0.18). Conclusion The hybrid approach for the treatment of AF was safe and effective in immediate restoring sinus rhythm and in its maintenance at follow-up. Our preliminary results show that both immediate and staged procedures show similar efficacy but this result is strongly influenced by the concomitant ablation of the Bachmann's bundle, which appears to be the most important component of the treatment strategy in order to reduce the risk of recurrent AF.