The consequences of academic dismissal for academic success

Ilja Cornelisz, Rolf van der Velden, Inge de Wolf, Chris van Klaveren

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

Abstract

Academic dismissal policies are increasingly implemented to promote academic success, with existing empirical evidence mostly restricted to short-run outcomes. This study examines long-term academic outcomes of academic dismissal for two cohorts of first-year bachelor students in Economics and Business at a Dutch university. Using administrative records, regression discontinuity design estimates suggest that academic dismissal does not relate to a difference in the propensity of graduation, nor to a change in study delay, when comparing students around the academic dismissal threshold. Not meeting this credit-threshold forces students to leave, and most decide to re-enroll in the same (43.4%) program elsewhere or at least within the academic domain (41.9%). Thus, while academic dismissal forces students to switch, its intended purpose of redirecting students to a different field of study is not observed. Implications for why academic dismissal might not deliver on the intended efficiency or effectiveness gains are discussed.

Original languageEnglish
Number of pages15
JournalStudies in Higher Education
Early online date30 Mar 2019
DOIs
Publication statusE-pub ahead of print - 30 Mar 2019

Keywords

  • Academic dismissal
  • higher education
  • educational attainment
  • student graduation
  • BINDING-STUDY ADVICE
  • EDUCATION
  • ABILITY

Cite this

@article{5f9c5139dc544988937e8eba1263821b,
title = "The consequences of academic dismissal for academic success",
abstract = "Academic dismissal policies are increasingly implemented to promote academic success, with existing empirical evidence mostly restricted to short-run outcomes. This study examines long-term academic outcomes of academic dismissal for two cohorts of first-year bachelor students in Economics and Business at a Dutch university. Using administrative records, regression discontinuity design estimates suggest that academic dismissal does not relate to a difference in the propensity of graduation, nor to a change in study delay, when comparing students around the academic dismissal threshold. Not meeting this credit-threshold forces students to leave, and most decide to re-enroll in the same (43.4{\%}) program elsewhere or at least within the academic domain (41.9{\%}). Thus, while academic dismissal forces students to switch, its intended purpose of redirecting students to a different field of study is not observed. Implications for why academic dismissal might not deliver on the intended efficiency or effectiveness gains are discussed.",
keywords = "Academic dismissal, higher education, educational attainment, student graduation, BINDING-STUDY ADVICE, EDUCATION, ABILITY",
author = "Ilja Cornelisz and {van der Velden}, Rolf and {de Wolf}, Inge and {van Klaveren}, Chris",
note = "Datasource: DUO data",
year = "2019",
month = "3",
day = "30",
doi = "10.1080/03075079.2019.1596076",
language = "English",
journal = "Studies in Higher Education",
issn = "0307-5079",
publisher = "Routledge/Taylor & Francis Group",

}

The consequences of academic dismissal for academic success. / Cornelisz, Ilja; van der Velden, Rolf; de Wolf, Inge; van Klaveren, Chris.

In: Studies in Higher Education, 30.03.2019.

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

TY - JOUR

T1 - The consequences of academic dismissal for academic success

AU - Cornelisz, Ilja

AU - van der Velden, Rolf

AU - de Wolf, Inge

AU - van Klaveren, Chris

N1 - Datasource: DUO data

PY - 2019/3/30

Y1 - 2019/3/30

N2 - Academic dismissal policies are increasingly implemented to promote academic success, with existing empirical evidence mostly restricted to short-run outcomes. This study examines long-term academic outcomes of academic dismissal for two cohorts of first-year bachelor students in Economics and Business at a Dutch university. Using administrative records, regression discontinuity design estimates suggest that academic dismissal does not relate to a difference in the propensity of graduation, nor to a change in study delay, when comparing students around the academic dismissal threshold. Not meeting this credit-threshold forces students to leave, and most decide to re-enroll in the same (43.4%) program elsewhere or at least within the academic domain (41.9%). Thus, while academic dismissal forces students to switch, its intended purpose of redirecting students to a different field of study is not observed. Implications for why academic dismissal might not deliver on the intended efficiency or effectiveness gains are discussed.

AB - Academic dismissal policies are increasingly implemented to promote academic success, with existing empirical evidence mostly restricted to short-run outcomes. This study examines long-term academic outcomes of academic dismissal for two cohorts of first-year bachelor students in Economics and Business at a Dutch university. Using administrative records, regression discontinuity design estimates suggest that academic dismissal does not relate to a difference in the propensity of graduation, nor to a change in study delay, when comparing students around the academic dismissal threshold. Not meeting this credit-threshold forces students to leave, and most decide to re-enroll in the same (43.4%) program elsewhere or at least within the academic domain (41.9%). Thus, while academic dismissal forces students to switch, its intended purpose of redirecting students to a different field of study is not observed. Implications for why academic dismissal might not deliver on the intended efficiency or effectiveness gains are discussed.

KW - Academic dismissal

KW - higher education

KW - educational attainment

KW - student graduation

KW - BINDING-STUDY ADVICE

KW - EDUCATION

KW - ABILITY

U2 - 10.1080/03075079.2019.1596076

DO - 10.1080/03075079.2019.1596076

M3 - Article

JO - Studies in Higher Education

JF - Studies in Higher Education

SN - 0307-5079

ER -