TY - JOUR
T1 - How Might we Build an Equitable Future? Design Justice, a Counternarrative to Dominant Approaches in Medical Education
AU - Anderson, Hannah L. Kakara
AU - Xu, Xandro
AU - Edwell, April
AU - Lockwood, Laura
AU - Cabral, Pricilla
AU - Weiss, Anna
AU - Poeppelman, Rachel Stork
AU - Kalata, Kathryn
AU - Shanker, A. I.
AU - Rosenfield, Joshua
AU - Borman-Shoap, Emily
AU - Pearce, Matt
AU - Karol, Courtney
AU - Scheurer, Johannah
AU - Hobday, Patricia M.
AU - O'Connor, Meghan
AU - West, Daniel C.
AU - Balmer, Dorene F.
PY - 2024/9/1
Y1 - 2024/9/1
N2 - Phenomenon: Marginalized individuals in medicine face many structural inequities which can have enduring consequences on their progress. Therefore, inequity must be addressed by dismantling underlying unjust policies, environments, and curricula. However, once these injustices have been taken apart, how do we build more just systems from the rubble? Many current strategies to address this question have foundational values of urgency, solutionism, and top-down leadership. Approach: This paper explores a counternarrative: Design Justice. As a set of guiding principles, Design Justice centers the experiences and perspectives of marginalized individuals and communities. These principles include mutual accountability and transparency, co-ownership, and community-led outcomes, and honoring local, traditional, Indigenous knowledge. Findings: Rooted in critical scholarship and critical design, Design Justice recognizes the interconnectedness of various forms of marginalization and works to critically examine power dynamics that exist in every design process. These co-created principles act as practical guardrails, directing progress toward justice. Insights: This paper begins with an overview of Design Justice's history in critical scholarship and critical design, providing foundational background knowledge for medical educators, scholars, and leaders in key concepts of justice and design. We explore how the Design Justice principles were developed and have been applied across sectors, highlighting its applications, including education applications. Finally, we raise critical questions about medical education prompted by Design Justice.
AB - Phenomenon: Marginalized individuals in medicine face many structural inequities which can have enduring consequences on their progress. Therefore, inequity must be addressed by dismantling underlying unjust policies, environments, and curricula. However, once these injustices have been taken apart, how do we build more just systems from the rubble? Many current strategies to address this question have foundational values of urgency, solutionism, and top-down leadership. Approach: This paper explores a counternarrative: Design Justice. As a set of guiding principles, Design Justice centers the experiences and perspectives of marginalized individuals and communities. These principles include mutual accountability and transparency, co-ownership, and community-led outcomes, and honoring local, traditional, Indigenous knowledge. Findings: Rooted in critical scholarship and critical design, Design Justice recognizes the interconnectedness of various forms of marginalization and works to critically examine power dynamics that exist in every design process. These co-created principles act as practical guardrails, directing progress toward justice. Insights: This paper begins with an overview of Design Justice's history in critical scholarship and critical design, providing foundational background knowledge for medical educators, scholars, and leaders in key concepts of justice and design. We explore how the Design Justice principles were developed and have been applied across sectors, highlighting its applications, including education applications. Finally, we raise critical questions about medical education prompted by Design Justice.
KW - Justice
KW - equity
KW - diversity
KW - inclusion
KW - design
KW - CARE
U2 - 10.1080/10401334.2024.2404008
DO - 10.1080/10401334.2024.2404008
M3 - Article
SN - 1040-1334
JO - Teaching and Learning in Medicine
JF - Teaching and Learning in Medicine
ER -