Further evidence that culture media affect perinatal outcome: findings after transfer of fresh and cryopreserved embryos

Ewka C. Nelissen*, Aafke P. Van Montfoort, Edith Coonen, Josien G. Derhaag, Joep P. Geraedts, Luc J. Smits, Jolande A. Land, Johannes L. Evers, John C. Dumoulin

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

119 Citations (Web of Science)

Abstract

We have previously shown that the medium used for culturing IVF embryos affects the birthweight of the resulting newborns. This observation with potentially far-reaching clinical consequences during later life, was made in singletons conceived during the first IVF treatment cycle after the transfer of fresh embryos. In the present study, we hypothesize that in vitro culture of embryos during the first few days of preimplantation development affects perinatal outcome, not only in singletons conceived in all rank order cycles but also in twins and in children born after transfer of frozen embryos. Furthermore, we investigated the effect of culture medium on gestational age (GA) at birth. Oocytes and embryos from consecutive treatment cycles were alternately assigned to culture in either medium from Vitrolife or from Cook. Data on a cohort of 294 live born singletons conceived after fresh transfer during any of a patients IVF treatment cycles, as well as data of 67 singletons conceived after frozen embryo transfer (FET) and of 88 children of 44 twin pregnancies after fresh transfer were analysed by means of multiple linear regression. In vitro culture in medium from Cook resulted in singletons after fresh transfer with a lower mean birthweight (adjusted mean difference, 112 g, P 0.03), and in more singletons with low birthweight (LBW) 2500 g (P 0.006) and LBW for GA epsilon 37 weeks (P 0.015), when compared with singletons born after culture in medium from Vitrolife AB. GA at birth was not related to the medium used (adjusted difference, 0.05 weeks, P 0.83). Among twins in the Cook group, higher inter-twin mean birthweight disparity and birthweight discordance were found. Z-scores after FET were 0.04 (0.14) in the Cook group compared with 0.18 (0.21) in the Vitrolife group (P 0.05). Our findings support our hypothesis that culture medium influences perinatal outcome of IVF singletons and twins. A similar trend is seen in case of singletons born after FET. GA was not affected by culture medium. These results indicate that in vitro culture might be an important factor explaining the poorer perinatal outcome after assisted reproduction technology (ART). Further research is needed to confirm this culture medium-induced effect in humans and to provide more insight into whether it is caused by epigenetic disturbance of imprinted genes in fetal or placental tissues. Moreover, embryo culture media and their effects need to be investigated thoroughly to select the best embryo culture medium in order to minimize or prevent short-term risks and maybe even long-term disease susceptibility.
Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)1966-1976
JournalHuman Reproduction
Volume27
Issue number7
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2012

Keywords

  • IVF
  • culture medium
  • human
  • birthweight
  • perinatal outcome

Cite this