Assessing the Expected Value of Research Studies in Reducing Uncertainty and Improving Implementation Dynamics

Sabine E. Grimm*, Simon Dixon, John W. Stevens

*Corresponding author for this work

Research output: Contribution to journalArticleAcademicpeer-review

12 Citations (Web of Science)

Abstract

Background. With low implementation of cost-effective health technologies being a problem in many health systems, it is worth considering the potential effects of research on implementation at the time of health technology assessment. Meaningful and realistic implementation estimates must be of dynamic nature. Objective. To extend existing methods for assessing the value of research studies in terms of both reduction of uncertainty and improvement in implementation by considering diffusion based on expert beliefs with and without further research conditional on the strength of evidence. Methods. We use expected value of sample information and expected value of specific implementation measure concepts accounting for the effects of specific research studies on implementation and the reduction of uncertainty. Diffusion theory and elicitation of expert beliefs about the shape of diffusion curves inform implementation dynamics. We illustrate use of the resulting dynamic expected value of research in a preterm birth screening technology and results are compared with those from a static analysis. Results. Allowing for diffusion based on expert beliefs had a significant impact on the expected value of research in the case study, suggesting that mistakes are made where static implementation levels are assumed. Incorporating the effects of research on implementation resulted in an increase in the expected value of research compared to the expected value of sample information alone. Conclusions. Assessing the expected value of research in reducing uncertainty and improving implementation dynamics has the potential to complement currently used analyses in health technology assessments, especially in recommendations for further research. The combination of expected value of research, diffusion theory, and elicitation described in this article is an important addition to the existing methods of health technology assessment.

Original languageEnglish
Pages (from-to)523-533
Number of pages11
JournalMedical Decision Making
Volume37
Issue number5
DOIs
Publication statusPublished - Jul 2017

Keywords

  • decision analysis
  • value of information
  • cost utility analysis
  • implementation dynamics
  • SAMPLE INFORMATION
  • IMPERFECT IMPLEMENTATION
  • FRAMEWORK
  • DECISIONS
  • DESIGN
  • MODEL

Cite this